37 Lit New York Gifts That Are Hotter Than A Fresh Slice

Updated: Jun 21 2023
37 Lit New York Gifts That Are Hotter Than A Fresh Slice
ThisIsWhyImKeepBuying is reader supported, some products displayed may earn us a commission. Learn more.

YERRRR, welcome to New York and the best, boldest, most awesome New York gifts around. These New Yorker-approved gifts will take you on a trip around the 5 boroughs of Manhattan, the upstate of the Empire State, and even out to Long Island. The Big Apple is a multifaceted place, which is why you'll find things and experiences on this list. Try a pizza tour with your friends, experience the Queens food scene, or hit Brooklyn for a graffiti lesson. You'll find the deep cuts here, like gifts that celebrate the history and majesty of Harlem, cookies from shops that don't get the press Levain does, and jewelry showcasing the MTA's rich history. From the Bronx to Staten Island, the bodegas to Fifth Avenue, everything that makes you say "I Love NY" or that makes you wanna move to New York City is here. Unlike the subway, there are no delays on this gift-idea train to the best places in town!

New York City Skyline LEGO Architecture

The New York City skyline is among the world’s most recognizable and it really makes for a show-stopping Lego piece. Remember your trip for years to come with this 598-piece architecture set, which you’ll use to build history, art deco, and modern treasures including the Flatiron Building, Chrysler Building, Empire State Building, One World Trade, and the Statue of Liberty.
$48 .49

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

We Are Happy to Serve You Coffee Mug

If you’ve ever stopped at a halal cart to grab a cup of joe and a bagel with schmear you’ve probably been handed one of these 10oz blue cups. The only difference between these and the OGs is that this one’s made of ceramic and will last you for more than a morning.
$12 .97

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Walk with Me New York Tour Book

HEY, I’m walkin’ here! That’s what you’ll be saying but in a chill way because you’ll be so mesmerized by the rich culture, historic landmarks, and genuinely beautiful architecture that you’ll see taking the walks in this book that you’ll be genuinely happy. Susan Kaufman has presented an idyllic view of the city that you'll love.
$21 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Statue of Liberty LEGO Set

Bring Lady Liberty home with you, but don’t worry, this gal will fit on the plane! The Lego version of the iconic statue is an incredible 17” in height and made from 1685 pieces. The set is part of their Architecture line, so it comes with a book full of facts and history about the statue.
$96 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Sabrett Onions in Sauce for Hot Dogs

Throw out the ketchup and replace it with this jar. Now you’re ready to eat the best hot dog ever. This is Sabrett sauce aka Onions in Sauce, the kind that you can usually only get if you pull up to one of the push carts with a hankering for some street meat and a $10 bill in hand.
$12 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

New York Public Library Puzzle

Witness the unique magic of New York in the wintertime with a puzzle of one of its most famous buildings around the Holiday Season. This heartwarming picture of the New York Public Library after a snowstorm is about 27”x20” in size and has 1000 pieces and perfect for working on when it's too cold to go outside.
$16 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Mike's Hot Honey

We don’t know who Mike is but we like what he’s doing with his hot honey. It’s 100% all natural honey infused with just the right amount of chili. It’s not too hot, so it won’t make you wanna scream, “Hey, I’m walking here!” but it will make you want to put it on everything.
$7 .80

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

New York City Homesick Candle

Central Park is the focus of this candle, and it’ll make you feel like you’re taking a stroll on the Literary Walk the week the cherry blossoms reach peak bloom. It’s 13.75 ounces of bergamot, lemon, and grapefruit with just a hint of jasmine and concrete. Yes, concrete. But just a hint for the sake of authenticity.
$24 .84

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Classic I Love NY Mug

I heart NY is a true icon, it is a living legend that will never die, despite recent attempts by the city to bring “We heart NY” into the common parlance. In a word: no. Celebrate the extraordinary work of simple typographic art and express your affection for the city with this simple masterpiece mug.
$13 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Long Island Homesick Candle

Can you pronounce Ronkonkoma and Patchogue properly? This is the candle for you! Enjoy the heavenly aroma of bergamot, sea air, jasmine, cucumber, and a touch of musk and apple. When people think Long Island, they don’t usually think of things that smell this good, so consider yourself luck to have the Homesick candle.
$38 .00

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

New York Mets Home Run Apple Bobblehead

You’re at a Mets game at the edge of your seat because a ball is sailing through the air. With this Limited Edition, you can remember the moment you first saw the Home Run Apple rise forever and experience the feeling of a home run anytime you peek at the 8” statue.
$499 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

CONTACT US