horror movies can't scare you maybe it's time to chase a cold case and dip your toe into the world of true crime gifts and all things terrifyingly real. A true crime l"> horror movies can't scare you maybe it's time to chase a cold case and dip your toe into the world of true crime gifts and all things terrifyingly real. A true crime l"> horror movies can't scare you maybe it's time to chase a cold case and dip your toe into the world of true crime gifts and all things terrifyingly real. A true crime l">

37 Bloody Awesome True Crime Gifts That Are Totally To Die For

Updated: Jan 30 2023
37 Bloody Awesome True Crime Gifts That Are Totally To Die For
ThisIsWhyImKeepBuying is reader supported, some products displayed may earn us a commission. Learn more.

If horror movies can't scare you maybe it's time to chase a cold case and dip your toe into the world of true crime gifts and all things terrifyingly real. A true crime lover will be obsessed with the devilish ideas here, which will only pour kerosene on the flames of their obsession with serial killer trivia and true crime podcasts. There will be no unsolved case when it comes to figuring out a true crime fanatic's birthday or Christmas gift, only answers that show them you're really in tune with what they vibe with. Help them Hunt a Killer with murder mystery games or puzzle that challenge them to figure out unsolved mysteries. Treat them to a homemade dinner with a serial killer cookbook comprised of the Death Row dinner requests of infamous killers. Give a true crime fan a little LOL-worthy merch that pokes macabre fun at the names they're obsessed with, like Ted Bundy and everyone's favorite, Jeffrey Dahmer. This list of gifts for true crime lovers really does crack the case on what to get anyone obsessed with murder (and getting away with it).

How to Get Away with Murder Puzzle Book

Be the person on the plane that no one DARES get in a conversation with by completing the puzzles in this book. There are over a hundred puzzles for you to try your hand at, including classics like cryptograms, anagrams, word searches, and more, all with seriously murderous themes.
$7 .61

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The Serial Killer Cookbook

Make the recipes in this book and you'll eat the best meals in your damn life. And they were the best and last meals of some other folks, too, because they were inspired by or exact matches to the last meals of a plethora of death row inmates. Enjoy the food and the stories in the book. You'll die happy.
$17 .95

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Unsolved Serial Killers: 10 Frightening True Crime Cases You've Never Heard Of

Dahmer, Bundy, Gacy, everyone who's into true crime knows about those guys, but if you're a real fan you need to break into the deep cuts. This book will present you with the stories of 10 chilling killers, their methodology, and their legacies. Each one will make your blood curdle and you might need to sleep with the lights on.
$11 .11

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Serial Killers: Adult Coloring Book

You're probably gonna want to order red colored pencils in bulk before tackling the designs in this serial killer-themed adult color book. There are 37 pages full of images of folks famous, or rather infamous, for what they did. Cut them out and hang them on the wall and attach with a little red string.
$8 .33

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Evidence Bag Zippered Pouch

This bag is evidence that you're a huge fan of true crime and that you have a sense of humor. What you put in it is totally up to you, but you'll have plenty of room for just about anything because the bag is roughly 7.25"x9.5" in size.
$9 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

A Haunted Road Atlas True Crime Book

From the bayou to the basement to the bar, if it's a location that's haunted AF, it's in this road atlas. Plan your next vacation around the tome, which is written by podcasters from And That's Why We Drink. You'll be scared, you'll be terrified, and you'll have the best vacation of your life following their advice.
$14 .21

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Death At The Dive Bar Murder Mystery Game

Test those skills you honed by listening to every murder mystery podcast under the sun with a game made for true crime fans. Hunt a Killer is a truly immersive experience and will challenge all your critical thinking and crime expertise to solve the case.
$22 .39

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

A Year of True Crime Calendar

You'll have 365 days of incredible stories and anecdotes about some of the world's most notorious killers. You'll find more than your average murderers on its daily pages. You'll learn about oddball laws, kids that killed, survivors that made it out, and cooks that enjoyed serving man (in the literal sense).
$10 .45

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The Book of Unsolved Mysteries

Treat a true crime fan to this book and they'll love you so much that your name will not be added to the list of unsolved mysteries between its covers. At least not by them anyway. There are 230 true stories covering everything from odd disappearance a la Amelia Earhart to the legend of Jack the Ripper.
$9 .40

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Body on the Boardwalk Immersive Mystery Game

Give your fellow detectives a call and see if you can solve the mystery of the Body on the Boardwalk. The immersive crime game takes about 45-60 minutes to play and is so authentic you'll feel like you're on the case of a real killer.
$22 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

I'd Rather Be Listening to True Crime Podcasts

My Favorite Murder, Someone Knows Something, Up and Vanished, if the very names of these podcasts leave you feeling a pang of longing, then these socks are for you. The cozy warm socks will keep you feeling not-so-murdery on a cold night.
$14 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The Ultimate Serial Killer Trivia Book

You've listened to every podcast, watched every show, and read every book but if you haven't read this one yet there are still things you don't know about Serial Killers. It details fascinating tidbits like the most bizarre serial killer motivations, why cannibals can stomach human flesh, and covers the most recent cases.
$8 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Unsolved Case Files: Murder Mystery Game

Put your cold case-solving skills to the test with a murder mystery game centered around Harmony Ashcroft. You'll have to utilize everything you've learned from the podcasts and shows and enlist the help of your friends to solve the three mysteries tucked into this one game.
$19 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Bloody Alphabet: The Scariest Serial Killers Coloring Book

There aren't enough red colored pencils or crayons in one box to take care of all the morbid and macabre in this book. Shade your way through 23 of the world's worst people. The pages are single-sided so you can tear them out after coloring and hang them on the wall.
$12 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Serial Killer Playing Card Deck

Introduce some cold-blooded killing to your next game of Go Fish with a deck of serial killer playing cards. Each is printed with a different killer and a fact about their murderous streak. Don't break these out around the kids, but do use them to enjoy a game of Solitaire as you're binging Dateline.
$14 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Mixology and Murder Cocktail Book

Whip up a killer cocktail or two using the recipes in this murder-themed book. If you thought a Bloody Mary was the most murdery drink, you'll think twice after sipping the bad and boozy recipes in the book, like the Amityille Amaretto, In Cold Blood Orange, and Sazer-Ax Murderer.
$11 .85

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Crime Scene Tape

One surefire way to keep solicitors and proselytizers off the porch is by wrapping the thing up in a bunch of crime scene tape. This is the same kind that the police use and has high visibility. There's 1000 feet of it so you can go hog wild setting it out.
$12 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Shh My Murder Shows Are On Stemless Wine Glass

The thing about people who watch True Crime shows is that they've seen so many that they could probably drop you and no one would ever find you. Heed the words on this stemless wineglass and STFU while they're learning new and more intricate ways of killing you.
$18 .99

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Serial Killer Trumps Card Game

Get to know some of the world's most notorious killers with a card game that introduces you to 34 of them. Which one reigns supreme? Only time and gameplay will tell as you make your through each psychopath's profile.
$12 .90

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

White Chalk for Body Outlines

The most polite thing to do when someone or something, say that plant that you kept forgetting to water, dies is to honor its life and memory by capturing its death in the most true crime way: with a chalk outline. There are 12 pieces of chalk in this box so you can afford to kill a lot of plants.
$4 .04

Price may change. Check the merchant site for current pricing.

Check it out

This may be an affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

CONTACT US